Best School Districts in Maine: How to Read the Rankings

The districts that appear at the top of most Maine lists are in Cumberland and York counties: Cape Elizabeth, Yarmouth, Falmouth, Scarborough, Kennebunk, and the Greely High School area served by RSU 51/MSAD 51. The harder question is what “best” means for your family, and whether the school your child would attend is the one a ranking praises. This guide covers who ranks well, what the data measures, where the lists mislead, and how to verify a specific address before you buy.

RealtorMaine

Find a Home That Fits Your Family

David Haydym brings 20 years of Maine real estate experience and local knowledge to your search across central and southern Maine.

Visit RealtorMaine

TL;DR

Cape Elizabeth, RSU 51/MSAD 51 (Cumberland and North Yarmouth), Yarmouth, Falmouth, Scarborough and Kennebunk come up again and again at the top of Maine rankings.
A ranking is often about one high school, not a whole district. U.S. News currently lists Greely High School first in Maine, but that is a school-level ranking.
Maine sets its own tests, so compare districts within Maine, not against other states.
Before you make an offer, confirm the assigned school for the exact address with the district, and look at programs, not only scores.
Top-ranked districts usually come with higher home prices, so budget the school decision and the housing decision together.

Which Maine districts rank highest
What the ranking numbers actually measure
Go beyond the rankings: the data you can check yourself
Verify the assigned school before you fall for a house
Programs matter as much as scores
Town tuitioning: a Maine detail that changes the map
Schools, home prices and your budget
Our perspective
Working with a Realtor on a school-driven search
A simple school-research checklist
FAQ
Sources

Which Maine districts rank highest

There is no single official list. Each ranking mixes different data, so the order changes from site to site. The names, though, repeat.

On the high school side, U.S. News lists Greely High School first in Maine, followed by Kennebunk, Cape Elizabeth, Mt. Desert Island, Scarborough, Falmouth, Wisdom Middle High School and Gray-New Gloucester. That answers the common question about the number one school in Maine: it is Greely High School in Cumberland, and that ranking is for a high school, not a district.

On the district side, MySchoolHives reports Cape Elizabeth Public Schools at 88% proficiency and RSU 51/MSAD 51 at 86%. Public School Review places Yarmouth Schools in the top 5% of Maine’s 189 districts, based on 2022-2023 combined math and reading proficiency.

Put together, the pattern looks like this:

District or school	Where it appears	What the figure measures
Greely High School (RSU 51/MSAD 51)	#1 Maine high school, U.S. News	High school ranking, including IB participation
Cape Elizabeth	88% proficiency, MySchoolHives	Share of students proficient on state assessments
RSU 51/MSAD 51	86% proficiency, MySchoolHives	Same measure, district-wide
Yarmouth	Top 5% of 189 districts, Public School Review	2022-2023 combined math and reading proficiency
Kennebunk High School	#2 Maine high school, U.S. News	High school ranking

Those are different yardsticks, so do not read the table as one ladder. It tells you which names deserve a closer look, not which one to pick.

What the ranking numbers actually measure

Most lists lean on a few ingredients: state test proficiency in reading and math, graduation rates, and sometimes college-readiness data such as AP or IB participation. Some add per-pupil spending and student-teacher ratios.

A few things to keep in mind when you read them.

Proficiency is a snapshot. It tells you how many students met a state benchmark in a given year. It does not tell you how much a school helped students grow, or how a child like yours would fit.

Data years differ. One site may cite 2022-2023 testing, another 2021-22. Plain Schools draws on 2021-22 reading and math proficiency, class-of-2023 graduation rates and fiscal year 2022-23 spending, with enrollment from 2024-25. Two lists that disagree may simply be looking at different years.

Maine tests are Maine’s own. Compare Schools USA notes that it does not compare schools across states because each state sets its own tests. So a Maine proficiency score is best used to compare one Maine district with another, not with a district in Massachusetts or Florida.

Small districts swing. Maine has 201 school districts enrolling 164,297 students in 2024-25. Many are tiny, and a few students more or less can move a percentage noticeably.

Context matters. Statewide, the on-time graduation rate is 88%, but it runs 94% for higher-income students and 80% for economically disadvantaged students. The same source reports 24% of Maine students chronically absent in 2024-25. A district with strong averages can still hide gaps, and a district with modest averages can serve a challenging population well. Rankings that track household income closely are partly telling you about the neighborhood, not only the classroom.

Go beyond the rankings: the data you can check yourself

The Maine Department of Education runs a Data Warehouse with information on students, education staff, schools and school administrative units, with options to compare across the state, SAUs and individual schools. It is the primary source behind many of the third-party lists, and you can see the underlying numbers without anyone’s scoring formula on top.

A practical way to use it:

Pull up the two or three districts you are considering.
Compare proficiency over several years, not just the latest one.
Look at graduation and absenteeism side by side.
Note enrollment size and trends. A shrinking district may be consolidating schools; a growing one may be building.

The district’s own site fills in the rest. Cape Elizabeth’s school department homepage points to a school building project, and the department is at 320 Ocean House Road in Cape Elizabeth. Yarmouth’s school department is at 101 McCartney St and lists 207-846-5586. MSAD #51 highlights a Multi Tiered Systems of Support approach to meet each learner’s needs. Calling a front office is a fair way to ask about class sizes, course offerings and what happens when a student falls behind or runs ahead.

Verify the assigned school before you fall for a house

This is the step buyers skip most often. A listing that says “Cape Elizabeth schools” or “Falmouth schools” tells you the town, not the exact school and not future assignments. Attendance zones within a district can be redrawn, buildings can be renovated or closed, and school choice rules vary.

Before you write an offer:

Call or email the district office with the exact street address and ask which schools serve it at each grade level.
Ask about change. Are boundaries under review? Is a building project, closure or grade reconfiguration planned?
Get the answer in writing when you can, and keep it with your purchase records.
Check the town’s own information. Some Maine towns do not run their own schools at all (more on this below).

If the property is in Maine’s Unorganized Territory, the process is different. There, the Department of Education manages school assignments, with specific schools designated by township location. The DOE’s Find Your School page is the place to look.

A caution on how a Realtor can help here. Agents are bound by fair housing rules, so we will not steer you toward or away from a neighborhood because of who lives there. What we can do is point you to the official sources, share neutral public data, and make sure the questions get asked at the right time in the transaction.

Programs matter as much as scores

Two schools with the same test results can feel very different. When you visit or call, look at:

Course pathways. Districts are experimenting with how students move through math, for example. The Maine DOE has published a math pathways presentation from Brewer describing flexible routes rather than one rigid sequence, which shows that strong programs are not limited to the southern coast.
Advanced options. IB, AP, dual enrollment and career and technical education programs. U.S. News notes that Greely offers IB coursework and exams.
Support services. Special education, English language learner support and interventions. Title I is a federal program that gives supplementary funding to schools serving students at risk of not meeting state standards, as Schoolwide or Targeted Assistance programs. A Title I label is not a mark against a school; it means extra resources are in place.
Daily life. Bus times, arts and music, athletics, after-school care, and how big the building feels to a nine-year-old.

Town tuitioning: a Maine detail that changes the map

Not every Maine town operates its own high school, or any school at all. Maine has a long-standing town tuitioning program dating to 1873, which lets students from towns without public schools attend public schools in other towns or approved private schools using public funds.

The Central Lincoln County School System (AOS 93) is one example where students have choice for grades 9-12, and each town pays the approved state tuition rate to the chosen school. For a buyer, that means the answer to “what school will my child attend?” can depend on the town’s arrangement and on family choice, not simply on the address. Ask the town office or district how it works for the specific town, and how transportation is handled.

Schools, home prices and your budget

High-ranking districts tend to carry higher prices, and that is a real cost to weigh. A smaller house in a sought-after district can cost more than a larger one a few miles away. Read how prices are set before you commit, including our look at why a median price is only a starting point. The same logic applies in any market: the factors that shape a home’s price, such as location and condition, are what separates a listing from its comparable sales.

Property taxes are the other half of the equation. School budgets are a major part of local tax bills, and rates differ between towns. Our guide to Maine property taxes and the homestead exemption explains what to check. For a wider budget picture, see what a Maine household budget buys by region.

If the top-ranked towns are beyond your range, look at neighbors with solid schools and more house for the money. These local guides can help you compare:

Saco, with beach access and a commute to Portland
Brunswick, a family relocation plan on a 60 to 90 day timeline
Auburn, with family buying checks
Lewiston, where newcomers get more house for their money
Augusta, a lower-priced central Maine option
Portland, the state’s largest market, with its own district and a wide price range

Our perspective

We have worked the Maine market for 20 years, in central and southern Maine, and the same pattern repeats. Families arrive with a list of top-ranked towns, then discover the right answer is more specific. A district’s average is not your child’s school, and the school is not your child’s experience.

Our approach is to treat rankings as a starting list and the district’s own data and conversations as the real research. We would rather you spend a week confirming the assigned school for two houses than lose a month regretting a purchase made from a headline. We give unbiased advice, with no pressure, and we are available beyond standard hours because school calendars and relocation deadlines do not follow office hours.

We also tell buyers plainly when a school-driven budget does not stretch. Often a neighboring town, a different house type such as a condo or townhouse, or a slightly longer commute puts a good school within reach. Since we can review documents for condos and townhouses, we can help you compare those trade-offs on paper rather than on hope.

— David

Working with a Realtor on a school-driven search

If you are relocating to central Maine or buying your first home near a school you have researched, we help you build a search around the districts you have verified, price homes against recent sales, and handle financing questions including FHA and conventional loans. We also work with sellers, investors and vacation property buyers across central and southern Maine. See how we work with buyers and sellers at RealtorMaine and tell us which districts are on your list.

A simple school-research checklist

List two to four districts, not one.
Compare several years of state data, not one ranking.
Confirm the assigned school for each specific address, in writing.
Ask about boundary changes, building projects and tuitioning rules.
Visit or call the school and ask about programs that matter to your child.
Price the homes and the property tax bill together.
Keep fair-housing principles in mind: base the decision on programs and data you can verify, not on assumptions about neighbors.

FAQ

What is the number one high school in Maine?

U.S. News currently ranks Greely High School in Cumberland first in Maine. It is part of RSU 51/MSAD 51. This is a high school ranking, not a district ranking, and the order can change when the data is refreshed.

Which Maine school districts are considered the best?

Cape Elizabeth, RSU 51/MSAD 51, Yarmouth, Falmouth, Scarborough and Kennebunk are among the names that appear most often near the top. Different lists weigh different data, so treat them as a shortlist and verify details with each district.

How do I find out which school my Maine house is assigned to?

Contact the district office with the exact address and ask which schools serve it at each grade level. In Maine’s Unorganized Territory, the Department of Education assigns schools by township. Where a town has no school of its own, ask how tuitioning works there.

Can I compare Maine schools with schools in other states?

Not reliably. Each state sets its own tests, so cross-state comparisons of proficiency are not meaningful. Compare Maine districts with one another, and look at graduation rates, programs and support services as well as test results.